In this blog post, we’ll examine the issue of interpreting quantum mechanics and its scientific implications, focusing on the Copenhagen interpretation and the many-worlds interpretation—two of the most prominent interpretations of quantum mechanics.
There is a Western proverb that says, “A watched pot never boils.” This means that a pot being watched never comes to a boil—it’s a way of saying that time passes very slowly when you’re waiting. However, in the world of quantum mechanics, something similar to this proverb actually happens. “An unwatched pot never boils.” According to the Copenhagen interpretation, if the pot is not observed, it exists in a superposition of states—both boiling and not boiling. As long as we do not observe this pot, it is neither boiling nor not boiling. Because the world of quantum mechanics is so different from our intuition as inhabitants of the macroscopic world, it is difficult to understand. Even Feynman, a leading figure in the field who won the Nobel Prize for his work in quantum mechanics, went so far as to say that no one truly understands quantum mechanics. The debate over the interpretation of quantum mechanics has evolved as various interpretations have been proposed, including the controversy between Bohr and Einstein. A prime example is the Copenhagen interpretation.
In the Copenhagen interpretation, all physical quantities have meaning only when they are observable. The physical quantities possessed by a physical object are not objective values independent of observation, but rather values influenced by the act of observation. This is because particles and atoms are so small that they cannot help but be affected by the measuring instrument. Among the countless possible electrons, one becomes the actual electron only when someone observes it. Quantum physicists who support the Copenhagen interpretation refer to this moment as the “collapse of the wave function.”
Through his famous thought experiment, “Schrödinger’s Cat,” Schrödinger unifies the microscopic and macroscopic worlds to point out the contradiction in quantum mechanics as described by the Copenhagen interpretation. Schrödinger’s paradox can be summarized as follows: if the wave function collapses due to macroscopic observation, it is unclear at exactly which point the wave function must collapse. In other words, Schrödinger raised questions about the very definition of “observation.”
It was Hugh Everett who came to the rescue of Schrödinger’s cat. Everett extended the equations of quantum mechanics beyond the microscopic world and into the realm beyond. The Copenhagen interpretation restricted the scope of quantum mechanics—as if by law—to the “microscopic world.” However, the equations themselves knew no such boundaries. He viewed the entire universe as a single, unified quantum system. As a result, the “collapse of the wave function” disappeared. Hugh Everett’s “Many-Worlds Interpretation” posits that because we ourselves are part of a superposition, we cannot observe that superposition. According to this theory, the universe is constantly branching out even at this very moment.
The Many-Worlds Interpretation expanded the existing quantum system from the microscopic world to the entire universe. Although Hugh Everett, the proponent of this theory, was marginalized because of it and left the physics community, the process by which he extended the equations of quantum mechanics to the macroscopic world and eliminated the concept of “wave function collapse”—a concept introduced merely for convenience—is quite fascinating.
Nevertheless, since the Many-Worlds Interpretation is effectively unverifiable, it appears to be closer to a non-scientific belief than a scientific hypothesis. The theory of parallel universes is unverifiable and is nothing more than a very dangerous notion that explains nothing. Most parallel universes exist in a decoherent state that has no effect on our universe, and we can never observe them. Ultimately, these parallel universes are all unfalsifiable.
According to Karl Popper, it is precisely falsifiability that distinguishes science from pseudoscience. It is impossible to prove that any scientific hypothesis is 100% true. This is because, no matter how much evidence supporting the hypothesis is presented, we cannot be certain that the hypothesis is true. On the other hand, it is possible to prove that a hypothesis is false—and this is precisely what falsification entails. Good science is knowledge that, while possessing numerous possibilities for falsification, has been accepted over a long period of time through countless empirical observations.
In fact, quantum mechanics was also criticized multiple times by Einstein, Podolsky, Rosen, Schrödinger, and others, and it grew stronger and more robust through the process of refuting these criticisms. However, Hugh Everett’s hypothesis completely rules out the possibility of falsification, as it posits that branching parallel universes exist in a state of entanglement with our universe. This indicates that his theory of parallel universes is not science but is essentially a form of pseudoscience.